The Best Baby Sleep Soothers 2019
The Best Baby Sleep Soothers 2019
Last updated: The Best Baby Sleep Soothers 2019. Getting baby to sleep has been an age old dilemma. Whether you call them sound machines, white noise generators or sleep soothers, these devices offer the same sweet nirvana: soothing a fussy baby. After testing 17 different baby sleep soothers, we picked .LectroFan High Fidelity White Noise Machine ($44.96) and Big Red Rooster Baby White Noise Machine ($16.99) as the best sleep soothers for baby.
Scroll down for our picks for Best Travel Sleep Soother and Best Baby Soother Nightlight. New to sleep soother shopping? Read our Things No One Tells You About Buying a Sleep Soother.
Types of Baby Sleep Soothers
Before we discuss our picks in depth, first let’s go over the basic options for baby sleep soothers. There are two general types of baby sleep soothers: machines that play “white noise” (such as a fan sound) only and those with pre-recorded nature sounds and/or lullabies. Additional features include night lights and smart phone control. We looked for the following features when we tested baby sleep soothers:
- Noise masking: If you’ve got older children or live in a noisy environment and your baby wakes up because of it, you’ll want a white noise that successfully masks the environmental noise.
- Timer: As we’ll discuss below in our Things No One Tells You About Buying a Sleep Soother, white noise machines should not be left on in baby’s room the entire night. An hour is usually enough. Hence, we only tested machines that had timers.
- Volume control with a low setting: Because babies’ hearing is still developing, we recommend using the lowest volume setting possible. See our Things No One Tells You below for further explanation.
- Number of available sounds: While many babies will respond well to a simple white noise machine with the sound of a mechanical fan, some folks may want more options. For example, a soothing lullaby or nature sound might be nice to introduce baby as a “time to get ready for bedtime” sound. And when babies grow into toddlers, having more options for a restless little one may be helpful.
- Ease of use: We especially looked for soothers that have easy to set timers. Some have smartphone apps to control the unit remotely, which seem like a great idea. But after testing, we discovered the apps are more promise than actual help. Apps were often difficult to set up and often plagued by short Bluetooth range and random disconnections.
Check out our top picks for white noise machines and pre-recorded sound soothers:
Best Sleep Soothers: Details
This white noise machine offers ten fan noises and ten “ambient noise variations including white noise, pink noise and brown noise.” In a nutshell, white noise can sound tinny to some folks—pink noise sounds more balanced to our testing ears. And brown noise takes that a step further, making more of a low hum.
This can get rather techy, so if you want to dive a bit more into the science of sounds, here’s a great video explanation:
Back to the LectroFan. In our testing, we found the LetroFan does an excellent job masking environmental noises like crying toddlers (and their crying parents who’ve had a tough day too), dogs barking or street noise. We like the multitude of options, although once you find one that works, it’s unlikely you’ll change the setting much.
Other features include a 60 minute timer (it fades out rather than just stopping) and volume control (be sure to use the lowest setting possible–see our 7 Things below). This machine is very simple to use, plus the noise is digitally produced so there are no repeated looping of sounds. Other cheaper sound machines we tested had that looping/repeating issue, which we found annoying (and so have online reviewers).
As for feedback from our readers, LectroFan gets great reviews overall, with a few complaints about a low-quality power cord. It some cases, it disconnected completely from the unit. Some readers replaced the cheaper cord and had no further issues.
Bottom line: even though the LectroFan isn’t marketed directly for parents with babies, it works as an excellent white noise machine.
Big Red Rooster (BRR)
Want more than just white noise? The Big Red Rooster (BRR) is a sleep soother made especially for babies and toddlers. It comes with fewer sounds than the LectroFan (six), but includes heartbeat, lullaby, ocean, rock-a-bye and twinkle noises as well as traditional white noise.
The BRR also has a timer with three options: 15 minute, 30 minute or one hour. While it comes with an AC adapter, you can also use it with 3 AA batteries—that’s a nice feature if you plan to travel (camping, hotel rooms with few outlets, etc).
On the other hand, we do have a specific baby soother machine pick for travel that is smaller than the BRR.
In our testing, we found BRR very easy to use with one caveat: pushing the buttons to change the volume or choose a new sound causes a sound loud enough to wake a sleeping baby in some cases. Quieter-to-the-touch buttons would be a welcome improvement.
The Big Red Rooster (which is actually white, not red) has had a few quality control issues that we see noted in online reviews. Some folks said the AC adapter stopped working after a time (although, oddly, it still worked with batteries).
A few dissenters thought the lullabies sounded “tinny.” We didn’t find that in our testing—although at $20, we weren’t expecting Dolby theater sound quality.
Bottom line: the Big Red Rooster sleep soother is an excellent baby sleep soother.
Not Recommended: Hatch Baby Rest
One of the top sellers in the baby sleep soother category is the Hatch Baby Rest Night Light and Sound Machine. After testing it and gathering reader feedback, we do not recommend it.
Hatch began as a small startup with an app-enabled baby scale called the Baby Grow. When founder Amy Crady Weiss worried about her newborn daughter’s weight gain, she came up with the idea of a smart changing pad that includes a scale to track baby’s growth metrics in an app.
After success with the Baby Grow, Hatch launched the Baby Rest in 2017. The app-enabled Baby Rest promised to combine several functions: sound machine, night light and toddler time-to-rise trainer.
The app allows you to set the lighting (dimmer, brighter, different colors) and the sound type and volume. Finally, it helps you set up routines for older babies and toddlers for bath time, bedtime and nap time.
All this sounds great, right? And it’s a best-seller. So why is it Not Recommended? In a nutshell, data privacy.
When you download the app and open it for the first time, this is what you see:
That’s right, in order to merely use the app to control the Hatch Baby Rest, you have to register for an account with your name, email address and a password.
And that’s not all!
One you give Hatch your personal info, you then come to this screen:
Yes, you read that right—Hatch wants to know your baby’s name, birthdate and gender . . . to turn on or off a nightlight! Hello?
At one point in 2018, Hatch also asked for you to turn on Location Services. That’s right—the app wanted to know your geo-location. This requirement was dropped after a 2018 revision of their terms of service.
So what’s going on here?
Hatch has had shifting explanations of all this intrusion in your and your baby’s privacy. Here is the September 2018 version, which basically says “trust us.”
In a nutshell, Hatch says it wants to “tailor programs . . . for your child’s age. We can also send you helpful sleep tips and articles to get your family on a healthy schedule.” What if you don’t want Hatch’s sleep tips? No app for you!
Earlier in 2018, Hatch explained one reason for the app data demands: many parents who purchase the Baby Rest also often buy their Baby Grow scale and having baby’s birthdate and other information is needed for the scale.
This doesn’t pass the smell test. According to Crunchbase, Hatch is a Silicon Valley based company with $7 million in venture capital backing. They couldn’t have coded the app to make this data ask optional? Right.
Meanwhile, there are now two apps: one for the scale and one for the soother sound machine/night light. So why continue to ask for baby’s birthdate and gender for what is essentially a night light with a speaker?
Hatch says it “guards it’s customers privacy,” but we’ve already seen this movie before. Hatch could easily be acquired by Google or Facebook and suddenly you and your baby’s data is in the hands of a company that may have a different perspective on privacy.
The take-home message: the Hatch sound machine works fine—but the privacy concerns make it a no go. Add to that complaints from users who say the app doesn’t work that well together with the sound machine and we suggest skipping this one.
Update June 2019: After we published this review, we heard back from Hatch’s CEO Dave Weiss.
Mr. Weiss clarified a few points we made in the article. Hatch only enables location services in the Android version of its app (the iPhone version does not enable this). That’s because Android requires this of app developers who use an app to control a device by Bluetooth:
Android users on 6.0+ must have location services enabled in order to connect to Hatch Baby Rest. This is a requirement from Google for any app connecting to a Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) device. Rest assured that our app does not collect or use location at all. More information about BLE location permissions can be found on Android’s developer site here.
At Hatch Baby, we’re all parents ourselves, and we have the same privacy concerns for our kids and families. We have designed our products to provide optimal performance for parents, while ensuring security. Please know that we take privacy very seriously and we never, ever share our customer’s information.
For Rest (our night light), we only require a name/sex and birthday (customers can enter any info they’d like here). Many customers use both of our products (Rest & Grow) with the same email address and the Grow app requires that info to accurately map a baby’s percentile on the growth curves used in the app. Again, if someone is only using Rest, they can make up a baby name/sex and birthdate. That info isn’t being used by us at all for Rest.
Our thoughts: we understand the trade-off with smart devices and registration—if you want features like sleep tracking tips, the company has to know your baby’s birthdate, etc.
Our point, however, is the same: the need to register to get access to most of the Hatch’s features should be optional. You should not have to give up all this info (even if you enter fake info) to do this just to control the Hatch Rest via Bluetooth.
Best Travel Sleep Soother: The LectroFan Micro Wireless Sleep Sound Machine is tiny. So tiny, we didn’t think it would work all that well as a sleep aid. But after testing it on various trips, were we wrong. While the sound isn’t going to fill a room, it’s enough to block most sounds in hotel hallways or grandma’s house.
The Micro offers ten sounds: five fan sounds, four white noise sounds and one ocean sound. It comes with a built-in rechargeable battery (USB) so you don’t have to carry batteries with you and the volume can be adjusted in tiny increments for perfect coverage. One bummer: it comes without a timer so you’ll have to turn it off yourself or leave it on all night (not our recommendation, see Thing No On Tells You below).
Best of all, the Micro weighs 5 ounces and is three inches tall and wide, making it easy to slip into your suitcase or bag. As a side benefit, the Micro allows you to connect your smartphone via Bluetooth connectivity so you can play songs through the speaker.
What’s not to like? The cord. (Why is it always the cord with LectroFan?).
Readers who’ve used the LectroFan Micro complained that the cord broke or became disconnected and wouldn’t charge. The cord is also pretty short and irked most testers, but you can use a regular USB cord to charge it if you need more length.
Parents also mentioned the Micro has a short life if you use it continuously. If you plan to take it on occasional trips to Disney World or grandma’s house, it’s a great option. But it doesn’t have the build quality to stand up for regular use day in and day out.
Best Sleep Soother with Nightlight: Details. Fisher-Price’s SmartConnect Deluxe Soother offers a night light with ceiling projection plus a sound generator with three sounds: nature, music and pink noise (which is like white noise, but not as annoying).
We tested this model and thought it performed the best among the combo nightlight/sleep soother sound machines designed for nurseries—as long as you don’t mind the somewhat glitchy companion smartphone app.
The “SmartConnect” part of this sleep soother is it’s Bluetooth-enabled app. You can adjust both the sounds and the lighting effects using a smartphone. The app also allows you to set a timer, choose from three light options (amber all-over light, softer blue light and base lighting–see video below), adjust the volume and change the type of sound.
So how does this work in the real world? When it works, the app is pretty cool.
But getting it to work consistently was frustrating for us (as well as other online reviewers we found). The app occasionally cut out or froze, which required reloading. Yes, the soother itself has manual buttons and they’re backlit so you can see them in the dark, but what’s the point of having an app if it doesn’t work all the time?
On the plus side, you don’t have to register or give Fisher-Price any personal data to use the app (unlike some other sleep soothers named Hatch).
Another disappointment for some people: the projected lights don’t move, they just glow steadily. We didn’t see this as a major drawback in our testing.
Bottom line: despite the glitchy app, we will recommend the Fisher-Price SmartConnect Deluxe Soother.
Why Trust Us
We’ve been rating and reviewing baby products since 1994. We test baby products here in our offices and we pay for all of test products ourselves. We look to our reader feedback to give us a real world perspective and we also evaluate consumer reviews posted online.
Here’s another key point: we don’t take money from the brands we review. No free samples, no sponsors, no “partnerships.” Baby Bargains is your independent and unbiased source for expert baby gear reviews. We’ve been writing and reviewing baby gear since 1994. Yes, that long!
How we picked a winner
We evaluated sleep soother by in-house testing and by sending products to parents to test. We check for ease of use, effectiveness and durability. We also gather significant reader feedback. The best sound machines meet our minimum requirements for a timer, volume control, variety of sounds, and masking ability.
Things No One Tells You About Buying a Sleep Soother!
Sleep Soothers have been controversial . . .
Parents are always on a quest to find a way to help baby get more sleep–mainly so they can get more sleep too! Newborns typically sleep only a few hours at a time because they are growing so fast and need to eat frequently. But once your baby reaches the four-month mark, your baby can learn to soothe itself.
But it just ain’t so easy! Some kids can Ferberize (the method of letting your child cry it out), but this method has its detractors and it sometimes doesn’t work for every child.
Others need to keep baby asleep once she’s nodded off but older siblings, dogs and street noises conspire to wake them up.
Sleep soothers that play white noise, music or nature sounds are a solution that some parents swear by. But they are somewhat controversial.
In 2014, the American Academy of Pediatrics released a study of 14 “infant sleep machines” or ISMs. The authors of the study tested their noise output at three different distances from baby’s ears (no real babies were tested). They compared the level of noise to the amount of decibels that would cause noise-induced hearing loss in adults. That number is 85 decibels or more. (We don’t have a level that would cause hearing loss in children–no one wants to test for that and blow out a baby’s ears).
Bottom line: 13 of the 14 ISMs were capable of delivering more than 50 decibels of noise even when placed at the largest distance of 200 centimeters from a baby’s ear. Since babies are more sensitive than adults, they postulate 50 decibels would be likely to cause some hearing damage. Three of the machines were capable of more than 85 decibels of noise.
Now here’s the caveat: It was a small study over five years ago. They don’t tell you which manufacturers they tested. And finally, they admit there is no real world proof that infants’ are suffering from damaged hearing because their parents used ISMs or white noise machines.
Here’s the AAP’s recommendations:
- DO NOT place the white noise machine near baby’s head. In fact, the farther away the better.
- DO NOT use the white noise machine at top volume, rather use the lowest volume possible.
- DO NOT use it all night. An hour or less is our recommendation.
. . .but other studies show they work
Another small study (using only 40 newborns aged two and seven days old) tested actual white noise machines to see if they did help infants fall asleep faster. They gave 20 babies white noise machines and compared them to a control group put to sleep with no sound machines. The result: 80% of the babies using the white noise machine fell asleep within five minutes. In the control group (no noise machine), 25% fell asleep within five minutes.
So what’s a parent to do?
- There are many apps available today that will test the decibel metric of anything. Just download the app and hold it next to the machine. Your goal is to get the sound below 50 decibels at the edge of your baby’s crib.
- Only buy a machine with a timer that you can set. Run the machine less than an hour at night.
- Place the sound machine as far away from baby as you can. Set the volume as low as possible.
- If it’s not helpful, stop using it.
Check back with us for future studies or information on sleep soothers.
Best Baby Sleep Soothers
BabyBargains.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com and its related sites.
WHO WE ARE