Best Tooth Fairy Pillow

Last Updated: May 15, 2023 @ 11:09 am.

Best Superhero Pillow: Tickle & Main Tooth Fairy Superhero Pillow

Tooth fairy pillows are a fun way to introduce this tradition to kiddos, especially those that are a bit skittish on the concept. Another good use: when you have two children in one room, you can hang the pillow on their door (and hence not wake up a light-sleeping sibling, ruining the effect).

For those kids who like their superheros, we’d recommend Tickle & Main Tooth’s Tooth Fairy Superhero Pillow. Here’s why

What We Liked

• 3 piece set with embroidered masked hero complete with hidden pocket for the tooth!

• Super cute!

• Affordable.

• Notepad for your child to write a note to the tooth fairy.

• Keepsake pouch with photo frame.

What Needs Work

• The notebook could better fit in the holder. It’s rather tight and some folks told us they couldn’t fit it in the holder.

Best Pillow + Keepsake: Girl Tooth Fairy Kit

If you’d like to keep your child’s teeth as a keepsake, we’d recommend this tooth fairy kit. Mama Bear Market’s kit would also make a nice gift. Here’s more:

What We Liked

• Set includes 3 pieces: pillow + keepsake box + receipts.

• Wooden keepsake box stores baby teeth. 

• Cute pink design with ribbons.

• Cool baby shower gift. 

What Needs Work

• Pricey.

Best Unicorn Pillow: Floss & Rock Fairy Unicorn Tooth Fairy Pillow

For unicorn fans, we’d recommend Floss & Rock’s Fairy Unicorn Tooth Fairy Pillow. The design is spot on!

What We Liked

• Ribbon enables you to hang on door.

• Super cute with ballerina fairy! 

• Heart shape pillow would make a nice shower gift!.

• Affordable.

Best Gift Pillow: Floss & Rock Tooth Fairy Pillow Mermaid

Got a friend whose baby is starting teething? This would be our pick if you want to give a tooth fairy pillow gift—super adorable and easy on the wallet.

What We Liked

• Includes satin ribbon to hang from door. If you’d rather not wake your child at night (accidentally, of course), this provides a more fool-proof tooth fairy visit!

• Super cute!

• Nice shower gift.

Why Trust Us

We’ve been rating and reviewing products for children since 1994! One key point: we don’t take money from the brands we review. No free samples, no sponsors, no “partnerships.” Our work is 100% reader-supported! Thanks for reading this article.