Pottery Barn Kids offers mattresses made by both Lullaby Earth and Naturepedic. We review both Lullaby Earth and Naturepedic. The Lullaby Earth mattresses ($199 to $380) appear to be discontinued mattresses no longer featured on Lullaby Earth’s web site.
Two Naturepedic mattresses are featured: the Organic Ultra Light 2 Stage ($349) and the Organic Oval Crib mattress ($219 intended for an oval crib like the Stokke Sleepi).
Pottery Barn Kids is also selling a Lullaby Crib mattress ($169), which is not made by Lullaby Earth (can they get more confusing?). This mattress appears to be made by Simmons, reviewed here.
We obsess over gear for families and the home . . . so you don’t have to. Baby Bargains has one mission: help you find the best gear for your family with unbiased reviews by experts with 20 years of experience. At prices that don’t break the bank. When you purchase a product from links on this site, we make a small affiliate commission. Learn more 
I purchased a Kendell crib and a Lullaby mattress from Pottery Barn for my grandchild’s visits. Your review does not mention anything about the firmness of this mattress. My adult children say it is too soft. I paid $169.00 and was told it is a good mattress. Do I need to change this?
Thank you,
Kathy Tomain
Hi Kathy: I think you are good—that is a good mattress. Plenty firm!
My son sent a Colgate mattress for $189. I agreed with them. It is much firmer than the Potttery Barn Lullaby mattress for $169.