Best Potty Seat 2017

Best Potty Seat 2017

Last Updated: Jun 13, 2017 @ 7:36 pmThe Best Potty Seat 2017. After comparing and testing dozens of potty seat (and cleaning up a lot of messes!), we picked the Baby Bjorn Toilet Trainer as the best potty seat.

Looking for a traditional potty chair? Read our Best Potty Chair below. New to toilet training? Read our 7 Things No One Tells You About Toilet Training for advice and tips.

The Baby Bjorn is a seat insert that attaches to a full-size toilet seat. It comes equipped with a unique adjustment dial to fit most toilet seats. It also includes an angled splashguard (handy to guide pee into the toilet bowl) and a contoured, molded seat for tushy comfort. Price: $24.

The Best Potty Seat

Baby Bjorn Toilet Trainer

This toilet seat insert is contoured for comfort and adjusts to fit most standard sized toilets.

 

Also Great: Fisher Price Froggy Potty

Fisher-Price Froggy Potty

Floor potties aren’t our first choice when toilet training (see our 7 Tips below for more on why), but some parents insist on a floor potty. Fisher-Price makes eight different floor potties for toilet training, but our favorite is the simplest: the Froggy Potty ($13). The seat has an integrated splash guard, handles on the potty ring, removable bowl and handle on the back for portability. Parents are enthusiastic about the Froggy Potty–their kids love it and it’s simple to use and clean.

Why Trust Us

We’ve been rating and reviewing potty seats since 2005. We’ve supervised parent testing of a wide variety of seats for ease of use and clean up. We also evaluate consumer reviews posted on sites like Babies R Us and Amazon, as well as our own message boards.

Here’s another key point: we don’t take money from the brands we review. No free samples, no sponsors, no “partnerships.” Baby Bargains is your independent and unbiased source for expert baby gear reviews. We’ve been writing and reviewing baby gear since 1994. Yes, that long!

How we picked a winner

Fisher-Price Froggy Potty with child

We evaluate potty seats with in-depth inspections, checking models for overall quality and ease of use—for example, testing with both boys and girls for ease of use and clean up. We also gather significant reader feedback (our book, Baby Bargains has over 1 million copies in print), tracking humidifiers on quality and durability. Besides interviewing parents, we also regularly talk with retailers and consumer appliance experts to see which brands are most trustworthy and other key quality metrics.

7 Things No One Tells You About . . .

7 Things No One Tells You About Toilet Training!

1. That’s right, it’s technically called toilet training.

There’s actually a lot of science behind toilet training and not all of it pertains to the potty you choose for your child. First, your child will need to be developmentally ready to toilet train. There is no magic age, although girls typically train earlier than boys. Here’s what your toddler needs to be able to do before you can start training (sounds like your kid is getting ready for the Avengers or the Olympics, doesn’t it?). This information is courtesy of Dr. Ari Brown, pediatrician and co-author of Toddler 411: Clear Answers and Smart Advice for Your Baby’s First Year.

  • Your child must be clued in to the urge to go, not clue in that she has already gone.
  • Your child must want to be clean.

If you don’t want to train in numerous fits and starts, make sure your little one meets these two criteria. Otherwise, you’ll be frustrated, your child will be frustrated and you could run into issues like withholding (not fun!). Talk to your family’s doctor if you have any questions about toilet training–they have seen it all!

2. Potties come in different styles.

Three styles to be exact. First you’ll see your typical floor potty, a self-standing potty with seat and removable bowl. This kind of seat is completely separate from your regular toilet. It requires you to empty the bowl in your toilet and may be susceptible to spills when emptying–especially if you toddler wants to do it himself!

Fisher-Price Froggy Potty

Next is the toilet seat insert. This type sits on top of the regular toilet seat of your full size toilet. No emptying of potty bowls, no spills and your child gets used to using the toilet he’ll use when he’s bigger but without worrying he’ll fall through the opening. Most inserts come in short and long lengths to fit the type of toilet bowl you have although some can also be adjusted to fit a wide range of toilet sizes.

Baby Bjorn Toilet Trainer

Finally, you may come across combination toilet seats. These are floor potties with a removable seat that can be placed on top of the regular toilet. So they get used to using a small potty on the floor, then graduate to the big toilet.

Our recommendation: go for the toilet insert. These are very portable, don’t make a mess and your child gets used to a real toilet experience.

3. You’ll need a step stool if you get a potty insert.

The advantage of a floor potty is your child has the floor to push off from when pooping. But the lack of a place to push off can be mitigated with an affordable step stool like this one from Primo:

Primo Step Stool

At a mere $6.50, this affordable step stool from Primo will help your child on the potty, washing hands and brushing teeth–whatever you need.

4. It’s called training, so you might be wondering if you need to reward your child when they do it in the potty.

You bet. But rewards can be a lot of things. For example, you could reward your child with cool big boy/big girl underpants. Or how about a sticker chart? This might work with some kids. Candy is a fall back that we won’t tell anyone about if you won’t. But in the end, being able to use the big potty just like Mom or Dad, etc. will be a big incentive. Remember to be positive even when it doesn’t look like it’s working the way you wish it would. Remember: your kid won’t be the only one in kindergarden who isn’t toilet trained, trust us.

5. Accidents will happen.

Stay cool. Go back to fundamentals. Look for any reasons why training is failing or your child has suddenly reverted to having accidents. Take time off and put your child back in diapers or pull-ups if you have to. He or she may just not be ready yet.

6. Don’t use pull ups to train your child during the day.

Pull-ups don’t teach children about the discomfort of being wet/dirty, so we don’t recommend them for daytime use. Our pediatrician expert Dr. Brown tells us Pull-ups can actually prolong toilet training. Let your toddler pick out some cool training underpants instead.

7. If you have to travel, make sure your potty seat can travel with you!

An advantage to a potty insert is it can even go in your luggage if you need it. There’s even a foldable potty seat insert you can buy for a mere $15. Floor potties are a bit harder to travel with unless you’re going by car. Then it’s easy-peasy to throw in the back of the car.

Jerrybox Foldable Travel Potty Seat

Jerrybox makes a highly rated foldable potty seat for $15 online.

Our Top Choice

The Best Potty Seat

Baby Bjorn Toilet Trainer

This toilet seat insert is contoured for comfort and adjusts to fit most standard sized toilets.