The Best Booster Car Seat 2017

Best Booster Car Seat 2017

Last Updated: Aug 11, 2017 @ 7:16 pmAfter researching and reviewing 51 different booster car seats, we pick the Graco Nautilus 80 Elite ($170 on Amazon) as the Best Booster Car Seat 2017.

Scroll down for our picks for Best Budget-Friendly Booster Car Seat and Best Booster Seat for Urban Parents.
New to booster car seat shopping? Read our 7 Things No One Tells You About Buying an booster car seat.

The Graco Nautilus 80 Elite works to 80 lbs. with the harness and 100 lbs. as a booster plus it can be used as a backless booster. The seat has enhanced side impact protection, an adjustable headrest and belt lock-offs, making it one of the most popular seats in this category.

(Scroll down for a detailed review of this seat).

The Best Booster Car Seat

Graco Nautilus 80 Elite
This seat morphs from harnessed booster (to 80 lbs.!) to high-back belt-positioning booster to backless booster.

Graco Nautilus 80 Elite

Graco makes the best-selling harnessed booster seat on the market and it’s easy to see why—the Graco’s Nautilus 80 Elite works with a five-point harness to 80 lbs. and then converts to a high back booster (120 lbs.) and even a backless booster for older kids (a feature the Britax Frontier does not have). Here’s what the seat looks like as a backless booster:

Graco Nautilus Elite 3-in-1 Car Seat

The harness is a big plus if you have a toddler who has outgrown his convertible seat, but wish to keep him in the harness for a while longer (the 80 lb. limit should fit most six year olds).

The Nautilus’ other features include over molded armrests (with side storage), three-position recline and decent padding. The seat is lined with EPS foam. Here’s a look at the adjustable headrest:

Graco Nautilus Elite 3-in-1 Car Seat

So what is the Nautilus Elite’s biggest selling point? Price: the basic Nautilus is 30% less than the Britax Frontier (see Also Great below) . . . and that’s nothing to sneeze at. As for reader feedback, the Graco Nautilus earns positive marks from readers for its overall ease of use. The IIHS ranks the Nautilus as a Best Bet when used in highback mode; the Britax Frontier earns the same rating.

A quick side note. You may be confused because Graco sells several different Nautiluses. Here is a quick review of the current line-up:

  1. The base model is the Nautilus 65 (aka Nautilus 3-in-1, $149) , which we picked as our “good” pick in this category.
  2. The Nautilus 65 LX ($169) has upgraded fabrics and buckle pockets to hold the harness when not in use; 120 lb. limit as booster seat.
  3. The Nautilus with Safety Surround Protection features additional, enhanced side impact protections. It is a Target exclusive for $162.
  4. Finally, we have the Nautilus 80 Elite, which is the seat we are focusing on for this review. Here is a video that goes over the seat in detail:

Flaws but not deal breakers

The Graco Nautilus 80 Elite isn’t perfect. Some readers tell us it is too snug to fit larger kids. In those cases, the roomier Britax Frontier Clicktight might be a better bet. The Nautilus 80 Elite also must be assembled, which includes several steps such as “Pull elastic loop on the seat pad through the vehicle belt guide on side of seat and attach to hook as shown. Repeat on other side.” Compare that to Britax where the seat basically comes out of the box ready to use.

We’re not saying the Nautilus 80 Elite is as fun to assemble as IKEA furniture, but we noted more than a few readers who said assembling Graco boosters had them swearing like a pirate. So just a heads up.

Who else likes it

About 79% of our readers gave it a four or five star review. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety gave the previous version of this seat (dubbed the Argos 80 Elite) a “Best Bet.” (The Nautilus 80 Elite is basically the same seat, new name).

Also Great: Britax Frontier ClickTight

Britax Frontier G1.1 ClickTight Harness-2-Booster Car Seat, Congo

If the budget allows, the Britax Frontier ClickTight is an excellent booster with great ease of use. $272 on Amazon.

The Britax Frontier ClickTight may be pricey, but it does offer features other seats don’t have—it works up to 90 lbs. with a five-point harness.

The Frontier aims for a market similar to the Graco Nautilus—after your child outgrows the five-point harness, the seat morphs into a belt-positioning booster to 120 lbs. The Frontier is targeted at kids at least two years old who have outgrown their convertible seats but aren’t mature enough to sit in a belt-positioning booster.

Britax has steadily improved this seat over the years (the most recent version on the market is the G1.1). Overall weight and height limits have moved higher and there are a series of small enhancements (example: the cup holders are inset in the seat, rather than stick out from the side, etc.). The Frontier 90 also has:

• A ClickTight seatbelt installation system. This system automatically tightens and tensions the seat belt—no more locking clips or concerns about LATCH seat limits. Here’s how it works:

Britax Frontier Click Tight installation guide

• SafeCell crash protection in base. Seen in Britax’s other models, this system absorbs energy in a crash.

• Higher top harness adjustment. The top harness slot is now 20.5″, which is the tallest in the industry. That will keep kids from outgrowing the seat in harness mode too soon. Other small improvements to the seat include a better recline feature and now the harness hides away when you convert the seat to booster mode (before it had to be removed completely).

Reader feedback on the Frontier has been positive. Ease of installation is one plus, according to parents, as well as the high weight limits and plush padding.

In the most recent booster seat ratings from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), the Frontier improved its ratings from a Check Fit to a Best Bet.  One point about this: this rating is for the booster mode only (not the harness mode).

FYI: If you want additional side impact protection, there is a special version of the new Frontier 90 with Side Impact Cushion Technology (SICT). This model is called the Pinnacle 90 for $250 to $260.

Flaws but not deal breakers

Are there any negatives to this seat? Well, this is definitely a big, bulky seat. Carrying it through an airport isn’t going to be fun (the Frontier is certified for use in an airplane, but only with its five-point harness—not as a booster).

The Frontier is 19.5” wide—that means fitting three across in a carpool won’t be easy for most vehicles. Also: the Frontier has limited recline settings and that might be a negative for some.

The price of the Frontier 90 is perhaps its biggest draw-back—the similar Graco Nautilus is about HALF the price. Even when discounted from the $330 sticker price, the Frontier’s $270 street price is substantially more than the Nautilus. And the Graco Nautilus has an extra use as a backless booster (the Frontier only works as a belt-positioning or high back booster).

Bargain tip: Buying last year’s fashion is a good way to save. Car seat makers like Britax often leave their seats the same from year to year, but change out the fashion. Last year’s fashions usually are discounted. How to find them? Check all the colors of a seat on sites like Amazon—more often than not, a few colors will be less expensive than others!

Who else likes it

User reviews for the seat on Amazon indicate “90% like it,” meaning 90% of Amazon reviewers give it a four or five star rating. That’s rare—even well loved seats don’t exceed 80% combined for four and five-star seats.

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety awarded this seat a Best Bet in high back mode.

Best Budget-Friendly Booster Car Seat

The Evenflo Maestro works both as a harnssed seat to 50 lbs. and a belt-positioning booster to 110. And all that for just $59 on Amazon.

The Evenflo Maestro works both as a harnessed seat to 50 lbs. and a belt-positioning booster to 110. And all that for just $79 on Amazon.

Best Budget-Friendly Booster Car Seat. What’s the best harnessed booster for under $100? The Evenflo Maestro has a five-point harness that can be used up to 50 pounds. After a child outgrows the harness, the Maestro becomes a belt-positioning booster up to 100 lbs. Best of all, the Maestro is just $79.

The Maestro has performed better than Evenflo’s other boosters, which are showing their age. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety gives the seat a Best Bet rating and it earned four out of five stars for ease of use. Reader feedback has been mostly positive. Fans cite the LATCH attachments, upfront harness adjustment and two crotch positions.

Critics note the harness must be re-threaded when you need to change the height and you have to disassemble the seat to clean the pad. But those are the trade-offs for the sub $100 price.

Bottom line: this is a better effort than Evenflo’s other boosters and it is affordable . . . with harnessed boosters soaring to $300 and beyond, it’s a pleasant surprise to find a seat that is both safe and under $100.

Best Booster Car Seat For Urban Parents

Best Booster Car Seat For Urban Parents. You live in an urban city center and need to take Uber/Lyft or a taxi with a toddler that’s outgrown a convertible seat. What’s the best solution? We have three:

1. Uber’s in-house car seat. If you live in New York City, Philadelphia or Washington DC, Uber offers a professionally installed car seat (the IMMI Go) for a $10 surcharge. A few caveats: your child must be at least 12 months old, 22 lbs. and 31 inches in height. Use the promo code CARSEATNYC10 to get your first car seat ride surcharge for free. Apologies in advance for parents of multiples: there is just one car seat per vehicle. Here’s an FAQ on how this program works.

2. The BumbleBum ($26 on Amazon) is an affordable, inflatable booster that is perfect for carpools or taxis. The Bumblebum’s small size makes it perfect when you need to fit three toddlers in one back seat. One caveat: this booster probably isn’t the most comfortable for long commutes or road trips. Note to urban parents looking for a lightweight option for Uber and Lyft: The BumbleBum weighs just over one pound.

BubbleBum Inflatable Booster Seat, Pink/Chevron

3. The Safety 1st Boostapak ($100 plus $12 shipping on Amazon). It’s a booster! And a backpack! The Boostapak works from 40 lbs. to 80 lbs. and even includes a storage compartment for a toddler’s stuff. Here’s what the Boostapak looks like when folded up and a video showing how it works.
Safety 1st Boostapak Belt-Positioning Booster Car Seat

 

More Booster Seat Recommendations

We believe the safest place for your toddler and young child is in a harnessed booster seat, like the ones recommended above. There are two other booster seat types—belt-positioning high back boosters and backless boosters. These are for older children who’ve outgrown harnessed seats. (Note that our top recommended harnessed booster converts into a belt-positioning and backless booster).

So when would you need to purchase just a belt-positioning or backless booster? Well, let’s assume you are in a minor car accident and decide to replace the booster. But now your child is six years old and has outgrown the harness limit. Then you’d go for one of these seats.

Best Belt-Positioning Booster

Graco's TurboBooster is tried and true—an affordable high back belt-positioning booster

Graco’s TurboBooster is tried and true—an affordable high back belt-positioning booster. $50 on Amazon.

The Graco TurboBooster ($50) is the best belt-positioning booster on the market today. It packs a good number of features into an affordable package: height-adjustable headrest, open belt loop design, armrests, back recline, cup holders and more. If you can afford the upgrade, the Graco TurboBooster With Safety Surround ($80) has additional side impact protection in the form of beefed up headrest and torso cushions.

Runner up: The Britax Parkway SGL ($128) gets excellent marks from readers for ease of use and safety—you get LATCH connectors and an impressive 120 lb. weight limit. Bonus: this seat has Slide Guard (SG)—it keeps a child from submarining out of the seat in a crash.

Best Backless Booster

Graco's backless TurboBooster works from 40 to 110 lbs and is under $30.

Graco’s backless TurboBooster works from 40 to 110 lbs and is under $30 at Amazon.

The best backless boosters on the market are the Graco TurboBooster backless ($27) and the Evenflo Amp ($28). Both are affordable and easy to use boosters for older kids who don’t need a high back booster.

The Graco backless option works from (roughly) ages four to ten (40 lbs. to 110 lbs.). Again, even though you could use this seat for kids as young as four, we’d suggest a harnessed seat until your child is beyond 80 lbs. or as long as possible.

Why Trust Us

We’ve been rating and reviewing booster car seats since 1994. In addition to hands on inspections of car seats, we have also visited manufacturer facilities and met with safety regulators—and when we travel, we pay our all of our own expenses. We look to our reader feedback to give us a real world perspective on car seats—our message board on car seats has 23,000 (!) threads. We also evaluate consumer reviews posted on sites like Babies R Us and Amazon.

Here’s another key point: we don’t take money from the brands we review. No free samples, no sponsors, no “partnerships.” Baby Bargains is your independent and unbiased source for expert baby gear reviews. We’ve been writing and reviewing baby gear since 1994. Yes, that long!

Learn more about our work and how to support our site.

How we picked a winner

Kid in backless car seat

We evaluated car seats with hands on inspections, checking seats for ease of use (installation and adjusting the seat). We also gather significant reader feedback, tracking seats on quality and durability. Besides interviewing parents, we also talk with car seat “techs,” certified child passenger safety technicians who install hundreds if not thousands of seats at safety check points nationwide.

We’ve been rating and reviewing car seats since 1994. During that time, we have also visited manufacturer facilities and watched car seat crash tests. While we don’t personally crash test seats, we compare our reader feedback with crash tests done by organizations like the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and Consumer Reports. We also look at third-party evaluations of seats by groups like the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), which focuses on booster car seats.

7 Things No One Tells You About . . .

7 Things No One Tells You About Buying a Booster Car Seat!

1. Booster seats come in four different flavors:

◆ High back boosters (HBB): Belt-positioning boosters come in two flavors: high back boosters and backless boosters. High back boosters have often been called “kid’s captain’s chairs,” which they kind of resemble. They are designed to be simple, but provide vital safety features for children who’ve outgrown a harnessed seats. These boosters properly position the lap belt on a child’s strong hip bones, rather than letting it ride up on the soft internal organs. And they provide correct positioning of the shoulder belt, so the child can comfortably wear it and get critical upper body support. The high back also protects the child’s head from whiplash if there are no head restraints in the vehicle, and the high back may also give some side sleeping support. ALL of these boosters require a lap and shoulder belt. FYI: Some high back boosters convert into backless boosters for older kids.

◆ Backless boosters: These belt-positioning boosters work the same way as high back boosters—they just don’t have a back. Safety-wise, these can be a bit better than a high back booster, since the child sits against the vehicle seat. They do the same job positioning the lap belt, and usually include some sort of strap to adjust the shoulder belt. But they don’t provide head support if you have low seat backs, and they don’t give any side or sleeping support. On the other hand, they are often popular with older kids, since they can be quite inconspicuous.

◆ Harnessed boosters: These are probably the most confusing “booster” seats because they sometimes morph from a forward-facing harnessed seat to a belt-positioning booster (and in some case) to a backless booster. With the five-point harness, boosters can generally be used up to 65, 80 or 90 lbs. Then the harness is removed, and the seat can be used as a belt-positioning booster, usually to 80 or 100 lbs. These seat also may be referred to as “combination,” or “combo” for short, from the two jobs they do. Our top recommendation on this page is for a harnessed booster.

The take-home message: we recommend a harnessed booster as the safest option to transport a toddler. Keep your child in the harness as long as possible (given seat weight and height limits).

◆ Special Needs Seats: There are a few seats on the market now that don’t really fit into any category. One is the Britax Traveler Plus, which is designed for special needs kids up to 105 lbs.

2. When is your child ready for the auto safety belt?

Some states allow children as young as six to legally ride in an auto safety belt (that is, booster seat use isn’t required). But there is the law—and the law of physics. Numerous peer-reviewed safety studies show that continued booster seat use is the safest course . . . until a child can SAFELY use an auto safety belt. When is that?

When a child is over 4’9” and can sit with his or her back straight against the back seat cushion (with knees bent over the seat’s edge), then he or she can go with just the auto’s safety belt. Still have doubts?

Try this Five-Step Test from Safety Belt Safe, USA:

1. Does the child sit all the way back against the auto seat?

2. Do the child’s knees bend comfortably at the edge of the seat?

3. Does the belt cross the shoulder between neck and arm?

4. Is the lap belt as low as possible, touching the thighs?

5. Can the child stay seated like this for the whole trip?

If you answered no to any of these questions, your child needs a booster seat, and will probably be more comfortable in one too.

This child passes the 5-step test.

This child passes the 5-step test.

3. Using a booster seat too soon can be dangerous.

You’ll note that some harnessed boosters have starting weight limits as young as 20 lbs.—that could be as young as a six month aged baby. But remember this: all boosters are forward-facing. And the current recommendation by safety experts is to keep your child REAR-FACING until age 2 or longer. So even though you could use a forward-facing harnessed booster for a one year old, we wouldn’t recommend it.

Also: don’t abandon the harness too soon. Yes, you could switch to a belt-positioning booster as soon as four years (or 40 lbs.). Our advice: don’t. Keep your child in that harness as long as you can (that’s why our top recommended seats on this page have top harness limits of 80 and 90 lbs.).

4. Your car’s owner’s manual is an important resource.

large_car-owners-manual

Sure, you probably haven’t look at it since you purchased the vehicle. But most auto manuals have detailed advice about car seat use. And that comes in especially handy when you start using a booster. That’s because some boosters can use LATCH—but your vehicle may prohibit this use when the weight of your seat plus your child exceed a certain limit.

5. Sitting in a belt-positioning booster requires maturity.

Good vs bad booster seating

Yes, we recommend using a harness as long as possible—but we are also the parents of two kids. And we remember the pleas from a toddler who didn’t want to sit in a “baby seat” (that is, the harness). The challenge: to use a belt-positioning booster, a child must be mature enough to understand the iron clad rule: you NEVER wiggle out from under the belt when the car is in motion. Some kids are ready for this and others need more time in a harness!

6. Only use cardboard cups in booster seat cup holders.

You’ll note that many booster seats come with cup or juice box holders. These are a great convenience, but most car seat makers only recommend putting cardboard cups or juice boxes in these holders. Why? In a collision anything heavier than a cardboard juice box or cup can become a dangerous projectile.

7. There isn’t one national standard for how long your child should be in a booster seat.

Booster seat use is regulated on a state-by-state basis, at least when we’re talking about how long kids must remain in a booster. Some states have an age limit, some a weight and/or height limit. If you’re unsure about the rules in your state, check your state Department of Motor Vehicles’ web site. Here’s a link to look at all 50 states at a glance.

safety iconSafety Alert

Certifications to look for when booster car seat shopping

NHTSA Ease of Use Rating: The National Highway Transportation Safety Administration (NHTS) publishes Ease-of-Use Ratings that cover four areas:

  • Evaluation of Instructions: Content and clarity of the instructions manual for the child restraint.
  • Vehicle Installation Features: Features that pertain to installing the child restraint in a vehicle.
  • Evaluation of Labels: Content and clarity of the labeling attached to the child restraint.
  • Securing the Child: Ease in securing a child correctly in the restraint.

Seats are ranked on a one to five star scale. While you can find these ratings here, we have also included NHTSA rankings in each of our reviews (see below).

Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) uses a six-year-old dummy to check the lap and shoulder belt fit of booster seats. Seats are award ratings of Best Bet, Good Bet and Check Fit. The last rating doesn’t mean a seat has failed, but requires a parent to double check fit in their own vehicle.

And yes, there are a few seats that are “not recommended.”

Here’s how the IIHS looks at booster seat fit:

IIHS standards for good and bad booster fit

Reviews of 50+ booster car seats

The Best Booster Car Seat

Graco Nautilus 80 Elite
This seat morphs from harnessed booster to high-back belt-positioning booster to backless booster.