The Best Baby Crib Mattress 2017

Best Baby Crib Mattress 2017

Last Updated: Jul 18, 2017 @ 1:48 pmAfter comparing 15 different crib mattress brands, we pick the Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Lightweight Crib Mattress ($259 on Amazon) as the Best Baby Crib Mattress 2017.

Scroll down for our picks for Best Budget-Friendly Crib Mattress, and Best Eco Baby Crib Mattress.
New to crib shopping? Read our 7 Things No One Tells You About Buying a Baby Crib Mattress for advice and tips.
Looking for reviews of individual crib mattress brands. Click here!

Naturepedic’s No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Lightweight mattress features closed-cell air pockets made from food-grade polyethylene. As a result, this mattress is half the weight of a traditional coil mattress. It runs $259; a dual-firmness model is $289. If you want a coil mattress, Naturepedic’s Organic Cotton Classic 150 coil mattress is a good bet at $299.

In a nutshell, Naturepedic balances the best of both worlds: organic cotton filling, a firm foam or coil innerspring AND a waterproof cover. All of Naturepedic’s mattresses contain no PVC’s, polyurethane foam or chemical fire retardants.

The Best Baby Crib Mattress

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Crib Mattress

Naturepedic’s No Compromise Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic mattress incorporates all the features we’re looking for in a crib mattress: light weight, no chemicals, waterproof cover, organic fabrics.

 

More details on our top pick

The Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic is our pick as the best crib mattress for most folks. Here’s a brief overview of the brand itself and more on why we picked this model.

Naturepedic, the Brand

Naturepedic’s owner Barry Cik got the idea for his company after a frustrating search for a crib mattress for his grandchild. Cik, an environmental engineer and hazardous material expert, was appalled at what he found on the market—crib mattresses made of petro-chemical foam, chemical fire retardants and more. “I knew all about vinyl/PVC, polyurethane foam, and the various chemicals contained in them and there was no way I was going to put my grandchild to sleep within a few inches of these chemicals” Cik said. In 2004, Cik launched Naturepedic as a more natural alternative.

The company has five goals for its crib mattresses: no harmful chemicals; no allergenic materials; natural, organic and renewable materials wherever possible; practical, easy to clean design; and third-party testing by GreenGuard to ensure they meet strict standards.

Naturepedic offers four series of crib mattresses: lightweight, classic, ultra and quilted/2-in-1. Prices range from $260 to $289.

Why this model

The No Compromise Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic mattress is uniquely designed with closed-cell air pockets made from food-grade polyethylene (no polyethylene). Called Wavesupport, the pockets are created with a wave design as shown below:

Naturpedic's Wavesupport

Here’s an actual photo of the Wavesupport:

Naturpedic Wavesupport photo

As a result, this mattress is half the weight of a traditional coil mattress. The cover is organic cotton fabric with a food grade polyethylene waterproof—making it both waterproof and dust mite/bed bug proof. Under the cover is another layer of organic cotton filling and there are no chemicals required to make it flame retardant. Another plus, the mattress is seamless with waterproof edges.

The No Compromise is GREENGUARD certified and the components are certified organic as well. This is Naturepedic’s best-selling model at $260; a dual-firmness model is $289. While these prices may seem high compared to other crib mattresses, it is substantially less than the competition in the organic mattress category with prices that can top $400.

If you want a traditional coil mattress, Naturepedic’s Organic Cotton Classic 150 coil mattress is our pick at $300. It’s made with organic cotton filling, a firm coil innerspring and the waterproof cover mentioned above.

Flaws but not deal breakers

The No Compromise is not exactly the cheapest mattress on the market, but it is comparable (and somewhat less expensive than) other organic, chemical free options.

In online reviews, some parents have complained their mattress sagged after only a short time. Other parents note that the measurement of the mattress was off and it was too small for their crib (leaving an unacceptable gap). Naturepedic replaced those mattresses that had problems. Overall, the company’s customer service is good.

Also Great: Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness All Foam Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness All Foam Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber’s Little Dreamer foam crib mattress ($196) features welded seams and a PVC-free, “hospital grade” vinyl cover. Bonus: it has two firmness zones (firm for baby, more comfy for toddler). Here’s a cutaway that explains the different layers in the mattress:

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer

The mattress comes with square corners for a tight fit, an internal fire barrier (no toxic chemicals) and medical-grade foam partially made form soybeans (making it just 7 to 10 lbs.). The mattress is easy to clean and made in the US. The company also touts its mattresses as hypoallergenic. Priced under $200, we thought this one was a good buy as competitors are creeping closer to $300.

Got an unusual size crib? Moonlight Slumber offers custom sizes of their mattresses. That’s unusual as most makers sell one standard size.

Overall reader reviews of Moonlight Slumber are quite positive. Parents note that the mattress doesn’t sag even after months and years of use.

Best Budget-Friendly Crib Mattress

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib MattressBest Budget-Friendly Crib Mattress. Yes, you can buy a safe foam mattress for as little as $56. The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is our top pick for budget-friendly crib mattress.

Sure, it’s no frills—a basic foam mattress with a single-layer vinyl cover that is easy to clean. Quality is good, but the single-layer vinyl cover will probably only last for one kid.No fancy eco materials or seamless edges, but an excellent deal is the budget is tight.

The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core crib mattress ($106) is a great runner up to the Safety 1st mattress. It is GREENGUARD certified to be low emission and, yes, the foam is partially made from soybeans. At just 8.3 pounds, this lightweight but firm mattress makes changing sheets easy. At $106, you can get the eco-friendly features without shelling out over $300.

Best Eco Baby Crib Mattress

Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Crib Mattress

Best Eco Baby Crib Mattress. Lullaby Earth’s Healthy Support crib mattress is made of polyethylene foam (a non-toxic, food-grade foam that requires no fire retardant chemicals) and weighs just 7 lbs. (Most other foam mattresses on the market are made of polyurethane).  It features seamless edges and GREENGUARD-certification. Price: $170. A 2-Stage version of this crib mattress is $200. The Healthy Support is an excellent, lightweight option at an affordable price.

Also Great: Naturalmat Coco Mat

naturalmat organic coco mat crib mattress

The Naturalmat Coco Mat crib mattress uses coir (from coconuts) for the majority of it’s filling. $384 on Magic Beans. Yes, it’s an expensive option, but checks all the boxes for both an eco-friendly and sustainable crib mattress.

UK-based Naturalmat offers three organic mattresses made of coir (the husk of a coconut), latex or mohair. Our favorite is the Coco Mat. The filling is made from coconut husk wrapped in organic lamb’s wool and then an organic cotton cover.

While the Coco Mat generally gets good reviews, it does have a significant disadvantage over other mattresses: there is no waterproof cover. That means you’ll have the extra expense of purchasing a mattress protector (Naturally, Naturalmat sells one from organic cotton for $65). And at $350, you’re already shelling out a significant amount of cash for all this eco-goodness. On the other hand, if you want to splurge, at least you know this is a high quality product.

Best Travel/Portable Crib Mattress

What separate mattress do we recommend for travel or portable cribs? The answer: none. It isn’t safe to purchase a separate mattress for portable cribs or play yards.

The Consumer Product Safety Commission says that when it comes to travel cribs or play yards, only use the mattress pad provided by the manufacturer (most, if not all, come with a mattress). Do not add an additional pad or mattress on top of the original mattress.

For more information about which travel cribs we recommend, read more here.

Best Mini Crib Mattress

The Best Mini Crib Mattress: Dream On Me 3" Extra Firm Portable Crib Mattress, WhiteWe like the Dream on Me Extra Firm Portable Crib Mattress for $24.24 as the Best Mini Crib Mattress. Yes, it is very firm, but that’s what newborns need! Weighing at 4.8 lbs, this mattress is lightweight . . . and that makes for easier sheet changes in the middle of the night. Yes, it also has a waterproof vinyl cover. Reader feedback on this mattress has been very positive, with folks saying it does the job at a reasonable price.

One point that can be confusing here: even though they have the same interior dimensions, mini cribs are different than portable play yards that have soft sides.

Above, we urge parents NOT to buy a separate mattress for portable play yards (sometimes called travel cribs or portable cribs). Why? That’s because those products come with their own mattresses or pads—the CPSC says to  only use the mattress pad provided by the manufacturer (most, if not all, come with a mattress). Do not add an additional pad or mattress on top of the original mattress.

Mini cribs, however, are sometimes sold WITHOUT a mattress. In that case, we’d go for the Dream on Me pick in this section.

One final caveat: some mini cribs have limitations on how THICK a mattress can be. The mattress here is 3″. Be sure to read any manufacturer limitations or safety guidelines on mini cribs.

For more information about which mini cribs we recommend, read here.

Best Waterproof Pad

American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Mattress Pad CoverBest Waterproof Pad. In this category, we’re referring exclusively to a crib mattress-size waterproof pad or mattress protector. We are not referring to travel mattresses or port-a-cribs.

Our top pick for waterproof crib mattress pads is the American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Pad. ($17.50). The front and back of this pad have a sandwiched waterproof vinyl layer to keep the mattress dry. Readers tell us they love this pad; it washes well and the price is a bargain. (An organic version of this pad, where the outer cover is made from 100% organic cotton, runs a couple of dollars more).

Also Great: Carter’s “Keep-Me-Dry” Fitted Quilted Crib Pad

Carter's Keep Me Dry Waterproof Layer Quilted Fitted Crib Pad

The Carter’s Keep-Me-Dry pad is an affordable ($24) waterproof pad that features a soft, quilted polyester top and waterproof vinyl backing. We like the all-around elastic and reinforced corners. The pad is machine washable.

Best Changing Table Pad

Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings 2-Sided Vinyl Contour Pad

Best Changing Table Pad. Changing table pads help turn a dresser or any surface into a changing table. A couple of shopping tips: look for a pad with elevated sides (see photo). This will help keep your baby on the mattress pad. A word of caution: elevated sides don’t guarantee your baby won’t still roll off the pad, so never walk away when changing your baby.

The best pick:  Simmons’ Two Sided Contour Dressing Table Pad with Non-Skid Bottom ($23, pictured). Also good: Summer Infant’s Contoured Changing Pad ($18, pictured). Both pads are available at Amazon.com, Target, Babies R Us and Walmart. If you’re looking for an organic or natural changing pad, consider Naturepedic’s Organic Cotton Contoured Changing Table Pad ($100).

Why Trust Us

We’ve been rating and reviewing cribs and crib mattresses since 1994. Yes, that long! In addition to hands on inspections of crib mattresses, we have also visited manufacturer facilities and met with safety regulators—and when we travel, we pay our all of our own expenses. We also evaluate consumer reviews posted on sites like Babies R Us and Amazon, as well as our own message boards.

Here’s another key point: we don’t take money from the brands we review. No free samples, no sponsors, no “partnerships.” Baby Bargains is your independent and unbiased source for expert baby gear reviews. We’ve been writing and reviewing baby gear since 1994. Yes, that long!

How we picked a winner

We take a hands-on approach to evaulating crib mattresses—that means checking density of samples for firmness and researching the various exotic materials some mattress makers use (are coconut husks safe for a baby to sleep on?).

We also gather significant feedback from our readers (parents like you who’ve read our book, Baby Bargains has over 1 million copies in print). We track mattress quality and durability—does that mattress start to sag over just a few months of use?

Besides interviewing parents, we also regularly talk with retailers of crib mattresses to see which brands are most trustworthy and other key quality metrics.

We meet with key company executives from the major crib mattress makers at least once a year, to stay up on the latest trends and research. Since we’ve been doing this since 1994, we have developed detailed profiles of major crib mattress brands that help guide our recommendations. See below for links.

Our Top Choice

7 Things No One Tells You About . . .

7 Things No One Tells You About Buying A Crib Mattress!

1. Forget all the fancy claims: all you need is a firm mattress with a waterproof cover.

What’s inside the mattress (foam, coil, latex, mohair, etc) is a matter of personal preference. After revewing dozens of studies on crib mattress safety, there is no evidence that one material is healthier (or more dangerous) than another . . . despite what you might read online!

A simple crib mattress starts around $50. It should snuggly fit your crib with no gaps more than two fingers length between the mattress and the crib (see graphic below).

Two Finger Test for Crib Mattresses

And while you’d think it would be no-brainer, there are some mattresses sold with NON-waterproof covers, so buyer beware.

2. That crib mattress could cost more than your crib.

Especially if you opt for a eco-friendly mattress or another specialty mattress. Many of these mattresses top $300 and even $400.

3. There’s no such thing as a “breathable mattress.”

Many parents are understandably concerned about SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome). Unfortunately, some crib mattress makers play on this fear by claiming their super-duper mattress made from special material (unicorn husk shavings?) is “breathable” and a lower suffocation risk than non-unicorn mattresses. Quick fact check: that’s FALSE.

These magical claims may lead some parents to think it is ok to put baby to sleep on their stomach. Wrong—the safest way for baby to sleep in a crib is on their back . . . on a firm mattress. (We have a full discussion of SIDS, see our other book Baby 411, co-authored by a pediatrician who is a spokesperson for the American Academy of Pediatrics).

4. Key quality feature to look for: triple laminated/reinforced vinyl covers.

These covers are more durable and less likely to tear (when you move the mattress around to change the sheets). Lower quality mattresses just have a single or double layer of vinyl.

5. Say no to that hand-me-down.

Your friend’s cousin has a crib mattress sitting in her attic that she’d love to pawn off . . . uh, we mean graciously give you. Politely refuse. Why? Bacteria and mold can grow in an old mattress, even if it has a waterproof cover—and especially if it has been stored in a dank basement or unventilated attic. We also suggest a new mattress with each baby.

6. Lighter = Better.

Babies do all sorts of things in cribs other than occasionally sleep. When it is time to change the sheets, you have to wrestle with that crib mattress. And here, lighter mattresses (usually foam) are much easier to handle than heavier options (most likely coil mattresses).  Another option: go for quick change sheets that don’t require you to wrestle with the mattress.

Let’s take a look at the structure of a foam mattress vs. a coil mattress:

Sealt Foam-Core Crib and Toddler Mattress

Compare the foam mattress (much lighter) to the spring version.

Sealy Posture Perfect Crib and Toddler Mattress

If you have to change sheets a lot (common occurrence!), the springs make this version a lot heavier.

7. Conventional crib mattresses are NOT dangerous.

Many expensive, eco-friendly crib mattresses are marketed with dark hints that conventional crib mattresses (made of foam or coils) are somehow dangerous. The online world is full of such stories:

“Common materials in crib, bassinet, cradle and porta-crib mattresses may be harmful and even potentially life threatening to your baby. The majority of mattress manufacturers use toxic, unsafe materials.” —web site of an expensive eco-baby crib mattress.

So let’s state it for the record: there is NO scientific evidence that sleeping on a conventional crib mattresses is harmful to your baby.

What about mattress materials giving off chemical odors?

Yes, crib mattresses are made of chemicals and some do off-gas when first removed from packaging. We do recognize concerns about bad indoor air quality, especially with newly built homes that are tightly sealed. If this fit your situation, look for crib mattresses that are GREENGUARD certified—this is an independent third-party test standard for mattresses that are low in VOC’s (volatile organic compounds).

Since babies sleep 12+ hours a day on their crib mattress, we can understand the concern that baby has a safe sleep space. But crib mattress marketers that play on these fears to sell $400 eco options often peddle junk science—these folks claim “polyurethane foam” and “waterproof covers made of polyvinyl chloride or PVC” are dangerous, cause cancer, etc.

Usually, these conspiracy theories trace back to a widely discredited campaign by the late New Zealand forensic scientist Dr. James Sprott. He claimed toxic gases from waterproof (PVC) covers and other chemicals in mattresses caused SIDS. If you wrapped a crib mattress in a special plastic wrap, SIDS could be eliminated, Sprott claimed. And of course, several companies spring up to sell such wraps online.

(Sprott, who died in 2014, was apparently a controversial character in New Zealand. At one point, after analyzing blood alcohol tests, Sprott said alcohol was not at fault in auto accidents. Instead, Sprott blamed rugby and “aggressive” males. Later, he tried to torpedo a “Red Nose” day charity event in New Zealand sponsored by a SIDS prevent group who had questioned his research).

After an exhaustive investigation of the toxic gas hypothesis lasting three and a half years, methodically examining every aspect of the claim both by reviewing existing research, as well as by commissioning new research, the Expert Group has concluded that there is no evidence to support the claim that fire retardants in PVC cot mattresses cause SIDS. (Limerick Report, 1998)

But that hasn’t stopped the fever swamps of the internet in keeping this false theory alive. Dozens of sites selling crib mattresses still quote this discredited theory.

Professor Barry Taylor, of the pediatrics department at Otago University, said SIDS researchers did not wish to comment on Dr Sprott’s passing in 2014, but they viewed his legacy with regret, noting the large amounts of time and money that were spent investigating his theory.

Reviews of 15 crib mattress brands

The Best Baby Crib Mattress

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Crib Mattress

Naturepedic’s No Compromise Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic mattress incorporates all the features we’re looking for in a crib mattress: light weight, no chemicals, waterproof cover, organic fabrics.